Tide laundry detergent detergency alleged substandard
Last Friday, the Shanghai Consumer Protection Board issued a "detergent compare test results," said P & G's "Tide," white and non-phosphorus detergent scouring the detergency of natural fragrance, reach national standards. P & G "cry foul", insisted Tide "is a qualified compliance product" and stressed that the national standard washing powder is recommended standards. It is the "Tide" second accused did not meet the standards.
Tide to a "failure list"
According to test reports, samples of 12 kinds of detergent, the "Tide" white and non-phosphorus detergent scouring the detergency of natural fragrance not reach the national standard; in simulated scouring test, 13% The washing powder is more difficult to remove Soy sauce And grease.
Learned that the comparative test of 12 samples by the staff from two large Shanghai Supermarket A random purchase, involving eight manufacturers, including a mystery, Tide, Ariel, white, clean, etc. Pa. Comparison of experimental basis for a recommended national standard GB/T13171-2004 "detergent" to. The results showed that Procter & Gamble's "Tide white and non-phosphorus detergent scouring natural scent" (Net weight: 560 grams, batch number: 20070123NJ), detergency do not meet national standards, and the remaining 11 samples are in line with standards.
In fact, in June 2005, China Cleaning Products Industry Association, a quarter of the year announced the results of tests of non-phosphorus washing powder also showed that Procter & Gamble and Henkel in the production of "white and scouring non-phosphorus detergent Tide" and "days of clear detergent" target in the detergency so there is no compliance.
P & G said the difference between the two standards
Last Sat, Procter & Gamble issued a to the Tide Consumption Who believe that, "Tide sections of white and scouring products include Tide detergent fully comply with the relevant Law Regulations on product quality requirements, a qualified compliance products. Products not only strict factory inspection, but also the professional authority of the State Test Of periodic inspection to ensure sustained and stable products to meet market standards. "
Tide brand manager of external affairs, said Chia-Si, Tide by the national authority of the professional testing organization "National Cleaning Products Quality Supervision and Inspection Center" test, the product meet the standards, better than the standard comprehensive detergency detergent.
For the test results, P & G believes that corporate standards and national standards differ. Chia-Si said, "difference is that P & G's corporate standards used in the detergency determination of the principles of the international standard method, select the consumer in their daily Life Frequently encountered among the stains were washed five actual comparison. The national standard is measured using three types of simulator technology stains. "He believes that assessment to a large extent affected by the determination.
Two standard "fighting" expert proposals on mandatory "national standard"
It is reported that China's detergent products, standards are recommended national standard –GB/T13171-2004 "detergent", enterprises can implement national standards and can also run their own companies to develop standards and enterprise standards just Technical Supervision Inspection and Quarantine of local record, the state encourages enterprises to develop recommendations to achieve and exceed the national standards of corporate standards to organize production.
Liby Enterprise spokesman Xu Xiaodong that the standard should be with its business market position and cost are related, not necessarily higher or lower than the national standard. The industry also said Mr. Chen, "if the product main attack in the low-end market, some standards may not meet national standards"
However, most consumers believe that based on national standards recommended by the test results.
Guangdong Day of Jun Valley Chamber of Commerce Deputy Secretary-General that the recent spate of two detergents industry testing standards of controversy. States should establish mandatory standards for washing powder, "this standard is the industry's minimum standard is to enter the market each detergent minimum threshold, then the future course of quality supervision and spot checks have all recognized standards based. "
I am a professional writer from Cheap On Sales, which contains a great deal of information about refrigeration vacuum pump , foreline, welcome to visit!
Processing your request, Please wait....
